Ahmadiyya and The Case of John Hugh Smyth-Pigott
The case of John Hugh Smyth-Pigott is the most irrefutable, clear, and undeniable case demonstrating the falseness of Ahmadiyya.
The founder of the ahmadiyya, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, made numerous claims, such as claiming to be a prophet. His followers often cite his prophecies as proofs of these claims.
Mirza himself has told us there's no better way to judge his truthfulness then his prophecies. “To Judge my truthfulness or lies, there is no better test than my prophecies.” (Ruhani Khazain, Vol. 19, P. 288)
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad claimed in 1902 that John Hugh Smyth-Pigott would die during his lifetime due to Pigott's claim to be Jesus/God. This did not occur. Pigott died in 1927, while Mirza died in 1908. Ahmadis say this was because Pigott repented of his claim and stopped. This argument can easily be tested.
I have proof that Pigott was claiming to be God in 1904, 1905, 1906, 1908 (3 months before Mirza died), and in 1909, after Mirza died.
Pigott, as we mentioned earlier, claimed that he was Christ, and in a christian background (he was a priest in England), he was also claiming divinity. When Mirza learned of this claim, which is effectively a rival claim to his (as Mirza claimed to be the Messiah) he sent a letter to Pigott. He dictated the letter to Muhammad Sadiq, a companion of Mirza that knew English.
Here are some excerpts from the letter:
“J.H. Smyth Pigott, Pastor of… London, has recently announced himself as God… on the 7th and 14th of September 1902… God has, therefore, commanded me to warn him… He does not only utter the blasphemy of calling himself the very “Lord Jesus”...I, therefore, warn him through this notice that if he does not repent of this irreverent claim, he shall be soon annihilated, even in my life-time… God has borne witness to my truth with heavenly signs shown in thousands… The death of Mr. Pigott within my life-time shall be another sign of my truth. If I die before Mr. Pigott, I am not the true Messiah nor am I from God… God shall bring the false Messiah to destruction within the life-time of the true one…
The letter is dated 24th November 1902. It is signed “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, The Prophet”.
The full letter can be seen in these two images, for anyone that wants the context:
The letter is quite explicit. Mirza says “If I die before Mr. Pigott, I am not the true Messiah nor am I from God”.
Here is an Ahmadi source (Ahmadiyya Gazette Canada, March-April 2010, English) authenticating the Pigott quote by publishing the above letter: http://ahmadiyyagazette.ca/magazine/39/03-04/AGC_Eng_Mar_Apr_2010.pdf
Go to page 29 if going by written numbers on the pages, page 31 if going by the PDF reader's numbering.
This proves the letter is authentic, as even the ahmadiyya have published it.
On the same page of the Gazette article, it says:
Unlike the case of Dowie, where he continued making false claims and angrily responded back to the Promised Messiah as through the media, Reverend Smyth-Pigott totally retracted public claims and retreated. It is perhaps for this reason he did not die in the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as). Indeed he lived on and died in 1927.
You can decide if this claim holds water when you finish this piece.
Additionally we can see on their website they reference a newspaper clipping relating to Dowie:
Here is a link to the page the above screenshot is from: http://www.alislam.org/egazette/egazette/april-2009-egazette/
If we lookup the newspaper clipping from the above screenshot, we notice it also has the Pigott prophecy:
The boxed text in the image says
“A sign of the evidence of God in my favor will appear on the death of Mr. Pigott, the arrogant pretender to divinity, who shall be brought to destruction within my lifetime…” (The Sunday Herald, Boston, June 23 1907)
The same quote is found on the official website of the ahmadiyya:
A sign of evidence of God in my favor will appear in the death of Mr. Piggot — the arrogant pretender to divinity, who shall be brought to destruction within my life time.
We also have a “revelation” about Pigott:
The source of this page is this pdf (see page number at the bottom of screenshot to find it): https://www.alislam.org/library/books/Tadhkirah.pdf
The above screenshot also confirms a letter in English was sent, and had been dictated to Muhammad Sadiq by Mirza.
So when did Pigott die? 1927.
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad died in 1908.
Now to get around this and maintain belief in Ahmadiyya they claimed he did repent, as is done in the Gazette article and Tadhkirah footnote from above.
This is easy to test.
Let's take a look at the timeline of events.
Mirza warns Pigott in 1902.
In a 1904 newspaper article it says:
The Rev. Smyth-Pigott, the self-styled “Messiah” of Clapton; and the leader of a sect called the Agapemonites is again receiving the attention of the London Press. It seems that the that the reverend gentleman whose claims to divinity caused a considerable stir some time ago, has left Clapton and is residing with his followers at the “Abode of Love” in Spaxton, Somersetshire, where he and about a hundred followers daily perform their mystic rites. He still claims divinity in blasphemous language. At a special gathering of his disciples on June 26 he again asserted his divine origin and dispensed blessings.
The same article says:
Many of the Agapemonites openly worship him.
This was in 1904, far after Mirza Ghulam's 1902 letter.
The source for the above quotes can be found in this newspaper clipping from 1904: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/WH19040816.2.13
In another newspaper from 1904 we have another report of him claiming to be God.
On Monday the 4th of July 1904, we have the following event:
On Monday the Agapemonites held a service at which Pigott again declared, “I am the Lamb of God,” at which the congregation fell on their knees and worshipped him.
The source for this can be seen in this newspaper clipping dated to July 8th 1904: http://newspapers.library.wales/view/3347303/3347306/45/Messiah
Important Note: “Lamb of God” is a Christian term used to refer to Jesus Christ, who Christians believe is God. For a Christian to claim he is “Lamb of God”, this is to claim he is Jesus Christ, that he is the Messiah, and (because they claim Jesus is divine), it is also a claim to divinity. That is why they were worshipping him in the above quote.
Here is yet another 1904 newspaper confirming he is still making his claims. He is directly quoted in the below screenshot as saying:
I am the Lord Jesus who has come again
An account is required for the above newspaper archive, but the free trial should give you three free uses. After going through the signup try the link above again while logged in to get to the page. This archive is linked elsewhere in this page for other papers.
So we've seen multiple different contemporary newspapers in 1904 that were asserting Pigott was still openly claiming divinity at multiple events.
This service where Pigott again claims to be God, and blesses his followers is from 1905. It is the account of a reporter who was present. Thus it is eyewitness testimony.
The same newspaper has an altercation with Pigott followers sent out to convert others:
“They told me that Mr. Pigott was the Messiah and that he was the Lord come a second time on earth... I spoke my mind to them... I said, 'just you get out of my house...' and they soon went when they saw I was getting my temper up.”
The source for this quote, and the above image is this newspaper clip from 1905: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/AS19050826.2.88
In a different newspaper in 1905 Pigott's close followers said “you are about to be admitted into the presence of the Almighty!”, to a registrar coming to visit Pigott. The same newspaper article had a discussion with the personal secretary of Mr.Pigott; Mr.Reed.
“The papers have said all sorts of things about us, and we are despised just as Jesus was when He came on earth. We have Jesus with us. Brother Prince said Jesus would come amongst us again, and He came and was revealed unto us at Clapton two years ago.”
After he says this the reporter asks:
“Do you mean Mr. Pigott?” —
He replies with yes.
The source for the above can be seen in this newspaper clipping from 1905: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/NZH19050918.104.22.168
Here is another 1905 newspaper:
Now we've seen three different contemporary newspapers in 1905 that were asserting Pigott was still openly claiming divinity.
A newspaper again publishes him claiming to be Jesus:
An account is required as mentioned earlier.
Just months before Mirza died he was claiming to be God:
“Mr Frank Edward Farncombe stated that in February 1908, he obtained admission to the Agapemone and had some conversations with Smyth-Pigott.
“A SACRED LIGHT”
Did you ask him how he established his claim to the godhead? – Yes: he replied something about a sacred light. I said it seems incomprehensible, and he replied: “The things which we deal with are a mystery unless the the initiated.”
– HAWERA & NORMANBY STAR, VOLUME LVI, 8 MARCH 1909.
So someone in February 1908 personally asks Pigott about “how he established his claim to the godhead”. This means people still understood Pigott to be claiming to be God. Pigott's reply is not denying that he is God, he just tries to answer the question as to how his claim is established. But he then says it's a mystery unless you are properly initiated. This, coupled with all the other newspaper clippings, show that he did not retract his claim to being God/Messiah/Jesus.
Mirza then dies on May 26, 1908, a few months after this February 1908 event.
After this, in 1909, Pigott again claimed to be God:
If one wants the source, see newspaper clipping here: http://www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/viewer/BL/0000321/19270321/027/0007?_=1497108726400
An account is required as mentioned earlier.
His sect/cult continued after his death and his followers did not stop worshipping him during his lifetime, and some continued to worship him after his death.
One of its cottages, North Gate, a four-bedroom gabled house built for followers in 1916, is for sale for £295,000.
After Smyth-Pigott died in 1927, the community went into gradual decline, ending with the death of the last surviving member, Sister Ruther, at the age of 90 in 1956. The following year, the Agapemone and its contents were auctioned.
It's clear Pigott did not repent. Pigott claimed to be God after Mirza's 1902 letter. In 1904, 1905, 1908 (3 months before Mirza's death), and after's Mirza's death. His followers said he was Jesus Christ who come again to this world and they openly worshipped Pigott in front of him throughout this period.
A reminder that at the beginning of this article, Mirza's 1902 letter said:
If I die before Mr. Pigott, I am not the true Messiah nor am I from God
This is pretty clear cut.
Mirza gave us a clear objective test and has told us if he fails this, he is not the true Messaih nor is he from God.